← All Episodes

When the Pro Forma Breaks: How Asset Managers Rebuild Business Plans With Better Data, Not Just More Capital

Episode 57 · 27 min · Nov 19, 2026

When the Pro Forma Breaks: How Asset Managers Rebuild Business Plans With Better Data, Not Just More Capital

Episode Overview

In Episode 57 of Peak Property Performance, hosts Bill Douglas and Drew Hall welcome Taylor Kolle, Senior Asset Manager at RREAF Holdings, to discuss how commercial real estate asset managers rebuild business plans when original assumptions no longer hold. From rising expenses and rent concessions to underperforming PropTech and fragmented property data, Taylor explains why better decisions, not simply more capital, are essential to protecting asset performance.

“And if you don't manage and own the data that you have historically, or you know, if it is a different property management software.”

Taylor Kolle

What you’ll learn

  • Re-underwriting properties in changing markets
  • Rent concessions, effective rents, and capital allocation
  • Measuring technology investments against actual ROI
  • Rising maintenance, insurance, and vendor expenses
  • Evaluating contracts and underperforming PropTech
  • Property data ownership and historical reporting
  • Moving beyond Excel-based KPI scorecards
  • Using operational data to improve decisions

Resources mentioned

Connect With The Guest

Taylor Kolle

Senior Asset Manager

Connect With The Hosts

Drew Hall (Co-Host)

Read the full transcript27,165 characters · checked against the original recording

Drew Hall: Welcome back to the Peak Property Performance Podcast. I am your host, Drew Hall, and today our theme is going to be When the Proforma Breaks, how asset managers rebuild business plans with better data and not just more capital. Now, before we introduce Bill and our guest, let me go through those administrative things that we always do right at the top here. Be sure to like and subscribe and share the podcast and Click on that notification bell as well so you'll get notified the moment that a new episode drops, which we tend to try to do about weekly, because this is how we are spreading the word on this peak property performance movement with the absolute goal of changing this commercial real estate industry for the much better. If you think that you would provide value as a guest here, we welcome CRE thought leaders from all stages of ownership and operations. So please reach out to us via the website, Peak. Propertyperformance.com is the best way to come in, or you can find us optic-wise on LinkedIn as well. That is okay as well. So, Bill, welcome.

Bill Douglas: Thank you, Drew. Always a pleasure to be here. today our guest is Taylor Cole. Taylor is a senior asset manager at Reef Holdings, working out of Dallas. He's the person sitting between the properties, the investors, and the business plan. And right now that means reworking plans that were built for a very different rate environment. What I appreciate about Taylor is that he's direct about what he's working on and what he isn't, including Prop Tech that made big promises but didn't hold up.

Bill Douglas: He's thinking hard about how to get property data out of exports and spreadsheets and into something his firm actually controls. So I'm looking forward to the conversation. Taylor, welcome to Peak Property Performance.

Taylor Kolle: Thanks, Bill and Drew. Thanks for having me on.

Drew Hall: Yeah, you bet. All right, Taylor, you have said that in some market cycles in the past, an asset manager could buy a property and let rent growth do the work. But what does the job actually look like now that's gone?

Taylor Kolle: Yeah, I think that a lot of the asset management responsibilities have grown significantly. A lot of asset managers are now required to wear a lot of different hats. And so, you know, you can't just be a financial analysis expert anymore. You need to understand, you know, complex risk mitigation strategies and capital allocation strategies and all the different areas you know complement each other. And so Asset managers can't just be, you know, a butter knife anymore. They have to be kind of a Swiss Army knife and be able to tackle different responsibilities and challenges

Taylor Kolle: New firms are looking for asset managers, they're bringing on, you know, experienced, well rounded asset managers rather than, you know, asset managers that maybe had throughout the last real estate cycle kind of an easier

Taylor Kolle: Time navigating those challenges.

Drew Hall: Yeah. Well, so how do you navigate differences between markets? I mean, if you have like no to low rent growth in some places and heavy new supply in others, how do those differences shape that asset management decision?

Taylor Kolle: I think there are a few different areas that also come into play, right? Like the capital allocation that you know the property has and the current structure outlined can you know affect how we kind of navigate the market. You know, a property that may need to conserve cash flow is not gonna be, you know, offering us significant of concessions or, you know, maybe implementing a capital, you know, plan. They're gonna be Holding that cash and a property that has the exact same operating, you know, kind of structure and outline that may be, you know, set up on a different capital basis is going to be operating completely different. And they may be able to utilize concessions with a greater kind of emphasis than properties that need to maintain kind of the go forward effective rent.

Drew Hall: Mm-hmm. I mean, do rising concessions change the way you evaluate? I mean, is it a flag of to something deeper? Or you I mean you mentioned a couple of times there, but specifically when those concessions are on the rise.

Taylor Kolle: Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, you know, supply has entered a lot of different markets and it's caused different operational challenges. And so you know, residents and prospective tenants of the property are you know using or looking for concessions at a greater frequency than historically they have been. You know, with markets that have had accelerated rent growth and stronger performance are not utilizing concessions as greatly as some of the other markets are. And so different properties, not only you know, in different markets, but with different capital allocations and different bases, are operating differently than they were historically, and utilizing concessions in different ways. Some are trying to avoid using concessions at all means to preserve kind of effective rents and asking rents.

Taylor Kolle: And holding flat, others are using them at a greater frequency to maintain higher rents. And a lot of times that can kind of mislead or misrepresent the true performance and go forward outlook on revenue.

Drew Hall: Okay. Yeah. So that asset management role is there's more complexity involved in it now than it has been in the past. So you've hinted recently also in terms of asset management role itself, that like the volume of even the opportunities out there, the posted jobs, for instance, for asset managers that are required or needed, is that also on the rise?

Taylor Kolle: Absolutely. Greater data availability and just the amount of data that we have readily available to analyze and make decisions based on that information has allowed a lot of different firms and groups to look for more you know talent and team members to aid in that, you know, analysis and decision making. and so I think not only that, but the just the rapid growth over the last kind of call it ten years in the cycle has sig significantly raised the ability to bring in, you know, more people on our staffs. And so not only are groups doing it because of growth, but they're also doing it because the need is truly there.

Bill Douglas: Taylor, wasn't it you that told me how many thousands of asset manager job postings there are on LinkedIn?

Taylor Kolle: I get probably a hundred different, you know, messages a day from recruiters and you know, I see fifty different postings a day. And so it's definitely out there and the need is there. It seems that the true experience level and the talent isn't necessarily.

Bill Douglas: I heard it was over eight thousand active postings right now for asset managers. I don't know if that's true or not. That's just what I heard. So don't declare that as a statement. All right. When the original assumptions in a business plan stop holding, how do you approach re underwriting a property? And where do you start? Like so many moving pieces lately.

Taylor Kolle: Well, I mean, I think it's important to understand that with pro forma it's at a point in time. And so markets will develop and change over that period of time. And so if it's been a year or, you know, five years or ten years, that pro forma may not hold up anymore. Market,

Taylor Kolle: Substantial movement or changes in the characteristics and fundamentals can really affect the assumptions and initial assumptions that you made during your And so a lot of groups have to evaluate where they are in the current business plan and what available options are out there. And so it can depend on a lot of different factors. It can depend on current performance at the property level. It can depend on the way that the property is capitalized or the deal structure is capitalized. And it can depend on a variety of different factors. the go forward outlook on a market. All of these different things play into how you Actively evaluate the current business plan or the initial business plan and re-underwrite based on the new assumptions.

Bill Douglas: So new assumptions. Maybe that's a good foray into how do you evaluate not just technology, but data and digital infrastructure investments. Cause those are the basis of anything you're trying to do, not you personally, but the industry is trying to do relative to AI and to predictive analytics and to true autonomy, which is where we're all trying to go.

Taylor Kolle: Yeah, I think it really depends. So technology, like any other capital project, needs to be evaluated with the same discipline. you know, a roof replacement and a technology initiative are gonna have varying different results of what you're looking for the property to perform. and they can have very different, you know, structures for the way that the pricing is, and implementation processes and what The need is that the property staff is going to have to operate. I would say technology is typically more of a broader kind of evaluation on our portfolio, more so than you know, an individual property and their you know roofs being replaced or an HVAC initiative replacing all the HVACs that may mitigate some of the operational expenses going forward.

Bill Douglas: Well, what makes a technology invent investment pencil versus you walking away? I mean, w what's a go versus a no go for you?

Taylor Kolle: I think it really depends on the reliability of their performance and the results that they're really driving. a lot of times you see big promises on what a firm or a company or a technology initiative will deliver and never really see those results translate. And so a lot of groups will say, Okay, we'll, you know, save you twenty percent on your water bill by evaluating this you know, usage and submetering and that may not actually realize. and so if they have a pretty dashboard or you know, some flash flashy charts, that doesn't necessarily produce true operational performance or business plan execution. And so those costs may not be justified at that point. If it's a relatively inexpensive technology, you may be able to justify it even if you're not seeing the true results that they initially promised. But a lot of times it's a lot bigger promises than it is true results. And so you have to be able to measure the results that those technology initiatives are driving, both at the individual level and portfolio wide.

Bill Douglas: Well, I love the fact that you're trying to measure it. And I also love the fact that you said technology is due t it should be under the same ROI focused scrutiny that an another asset is, because I mean Drew will nod his head when I say this, but we at least for the last decade have heard technology's an expense and I just can't take an expense right now. And we believe anything digital or data or technology should be treated like an asset. And if it's n doesn't have a known return, it should not be procured. Like it's just that straightforward.

Bill Douglas: You should know what it is and hats off to you for actually measuring it. That's good. We don't hear that much in the industry. And we wished it was more prevalent. Like technology is an expense and nobody can just take an expense out of Opex. Well, that's not the discussion we're trying to have here.

Taylor Kolle: Yeah. A lot of times I too, I think vendors with that being the case, we've seen rising costs across all of our different technology platforms and softwares. And so it's become more of a question of is this increase in cost justified to the true performance that it provides? Sometimes it's not always the performance that the proper or the technology is performing. It is it

Taylor Kolle: The performance greater than this software or this other option. and so it's been a lot of kind of discipline in terms of how we evaluate different platforms and different softwares. And sometimes we have to pivot to a new platform based on, you know, the rising costs and them not justifying the cost with the performance increase.

Drew Hall: Yeah. Well, so I mean, yeah, that's a little bit about expenses in the technology piece of it all, the OT. what about expenses in j in general? Just like holistically looking at the asset. Expenses have obviously been in focus for years, but can you think of an example or two where you've seen those costs move in ways that surprised you? And like how did you use analysis to figure out why?

Taylor Kolle: Yeah, I a lot of different properties over the past few years have experienced significant expense increases, not only, you know, on the software and the vendor side, but also on our repairs and maintenance and typical turn items. And so a paint service that used to cost two hundred and fifty bucks for a five hundred square foot unit now may cost nine hundred dollars. and it's the same service. The paint has maybe gone up and labor costs have maybe gone up, but you know, it the increase is not justifying the difference. And so a lot of times what we've had to do is get very disciplined with our analysis on specific vendors and form relationships that are more of a strategic partnership than you know really just looking at the individual item. The other thing is a lot of different services, especially with unit turnover, can vary greatly depending on kind of the unit and What that service truly is. So paint service for 500 bucks or 500 bucks on a 500 square foot unit and another one that is 750 square foot, and maybe they're not charging the same rate, maybe it's 900. Looking at those kind of expense trends can kind of show us a different perspective, and maybe we need to pivot and realign on our vendors, or maybe we need to figure out a standardized scope across different services. And so that's one of the operational challenges that we've definitely had to navigate over the last few years is just how great expenses have gone without really a justifiable cost being the reason.

Drew Hall: Yeah. Well, so yeah, what about insurance itself? I mean, that's always a big factor, but you know, with a mind keeping a mind toward the vendor's requirements or I sorry, your requirements for the vendor, I guess, is ever changing insurance, especially costs, is that a big driver?

Taylor Kolle: Absolutely. I mean, we saw substantial increases due to the external factors, a lot of you know, issues with rising premiums being carried by carriers. so that was one kind of factor that was a result of a lot of different issues going on, especially with COVID and kind of some of the natural disasters experience. But there's also the other side, which is different compliance requirements based on different lenders that. carrying that in their loan agreement with us and different requirements from our partnerships. And so there's a lot of varying factors that may cause those insurance requirements to be differing at different levels at the property. There are some ways that we can mitigate a lot of that. And so one of the ways that we've worked to do that is different services may have a different risk threshold. So for a paint service, you're not gonna need a million dollars worth of coverage necessarily, but you know, for a HVAC replacement or plumbing issues, you may want a more substantial premium being held or deductible. and so a lot of times the insurance level that our carriers are or our vendors are carrying can differ based on also the services that they're providing.

Drew Hall: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, I you touched on it briefly a few minutes ago, but when you think about a prop tech product that makes a big promise but doesn't really quite d hold up to that promise, and you're in there with analysis to decide whether or not it's worth keeping. Take us through that a little bit. you know, how deep can you go before you have to declare like, man, it's time to make a change here.

Taylor Kolle: I think it depends really on going back to kind of measuring their performance. If they're not driving results and we've, you know, held that service for several years or that vendor, then we need to see why our costs are increasing and how their services are changing to better aid our analysis and our decision making on the go forward. a lot of times it's hard to justify if you can't measure true performance and true output and how that translates to the property level.

Drew Hall: Yeah, definitely. Well, and here again, I find myself thinking about like if it's a known, unknown. You know that you're supposed to have a data point that you just aren't getting out of the system, for instance. Isn't is it a matter of a misconfiguration or is it truly a shortfall of that particular prop tech product versus if it's an unknown, unknown. You're not even really sure what the potential is. So those are very different scenarios. But certainly if you've experienced positivity in one asset somewhere in the portfolio and you know that it's missing elsewhere, then those are easier to spot a lot of times.

Taylor Kolle: Well, a lot of times there's broader initiatives that we, you know, may roll out across the portfolio and certain properties may not be seeing the same level of results that other properties are. And so it may be more of a decision of, okay, this may increase costs across other properties, but it's affecting this property's current performance. And so a lot of times there isn't necessarily just a blanketed response or way that we can navigate that. Sometimes there's

Taylor Kolle: Broader analysis that needs to be done on a portfolio level rather than just the individual property.

Bill Douglas: Well, we see I should I see a lot in the industry. People know that the vendor or the OT platform isn't providing value, but the I sh I'm gonna say the cost of change, but it's an emotional and a time cost. To make a change is more egregious on them or their company than to let it just ride. So we see a lot of just let it ride. I don't want to change. The resistance to change is so high in humans, period.

Bill Douglas: But sometimes it's high just because of the time or the risk to make a change to another vendor because somebody's gonna have to pick it, right? So we unfortunately we see a lot of that. And therefore, not just Prop Tech, but any technology just keeps writing. And we had somebody on here a couple of weeks ago talking about they're still paying elevator contracts that are forty years old. Like they never bothered shopping them because they're scared of what it might entail. Like and they keep getting these five to ten percent increases every year.

Bill Douglas: You do that for a decade, the last decade, and it's egregious. All right. that was more of a statement than a question, but you're welcome to argue it if that's not what you're

Taylor Kolle: No, I think that's good. I think that's been a more definitely a more increasing kind of issue that we've had to tackle. Like for your example for elevator contracts, that's something that we've actually had to start evaluating. and so there's different contracts in place that we've left over time. and it's notorious across the industry. But with the way that expenses have gone up with property taxes, insurance, turn costs, RM. and different tariffs you know affecting the materials that we're getting. It's caused us to have to look for even the incremental savings in something like an elevator contract.

Bill Douglas: Well, I picked on elevator contracts cause it was easy and old, but why doesn't the same thing apply to a PMS or lighting control or an access control or a video security control contract or an ISP contract? Wha why aren't those scrutinized?

Taylor Kolle: I think they are, but the actual replacement of the product is a harder challenge to navigate. getting a different vendor to service your contracts is or your elevator is gonna be an easier kind of component to switch out at a property than completely changing your property management software. There's different requirements, you know, of how you train your staff and how you implement, you know, new policies and procedures and make those additional changes.

Bill Douglas: I can see that. Doesn't mean we can't and shouldn't do it, but in the market we're seeing with a increased expenses across the board, we are seeing more people pay attention to those things. So that to us is optimistic. switch gears a little bit. You told me that a lot of your KPIs today live in Excel scorecards fed by exports from the PMS property management system. So what would it take to move from that to a place where your firm truly owns and can use the data? Any way they want, not just in a PMS.

Taylor Kolle: I mean that's a huge kind of issue going on right now. And a lot of groups are having to make a more dedicated commitment to owning their data and having historical data readily available. there's no way for us to evaluate go forward performance without reviewing historical trends. And if you don't manage and own the data that you have historically, or you know, if it is a different property management software. It's gonna be difficult for you to onboard to a different one if you don't have the data from the prior. a lot of data management, data discipline, and actually having that data stored somewhere that it can be accessed by your team and managed in a more responsible and disciplined way.

Bill Douglas: You mean in like your own data lake for that property with your own property brand? Yeah. That's a good thing to have. So what are the limits of a KPI scorecard when you're trying to see the driving data, not just the result? Like we talk a lot about forward looking KPIs, not just backwards, you know. Rear mirror rear view mirror KPIs. Like your financials are rear view mirror. You get at least fifteen days after they're out of date, right? So

Bill Douglas: You know, what's are the limits of what you're doing now with a KPI scorecard? What

Taylor Kolle: I think the KPI scorecard is more of a s sniff test, if you will. it may show that occupancy has declined or you're looking at it at a point in time, but to your point, it's a historical or it's a standalone figure and it doesn't necessarily explain what the true underlying factors are that contribute to that. And so your occupancy may be one thing, but it may be, you know, a pricing or

Taylor Kolle: Concessions or a comp or a product issue or some other kind of factor in the market that's causing that occupancy to decline. And those all have different decision making trees and how you approach and navigate that problem and fix it.

Bill Douglas: Well, beyond PMS and market data, what operating data from the buildings themselves would be most useful to you?

Taylor Kolle: There's a wealth of different, you know, factors that they provide in terms of the data. I think for kind of the hard data, like looking at maintenance turn times and the amount of work orders that are outstanding, those are all very important data points that are a little bit harder to capture a lot of times. A maintenance guy may not throw in a work order for a light bulb change, but that still took thirty minutes for them to complete. And so Centralizing a lot of that data, making it easy to review and evaluate and input by our teams is crucial. otherwise the data that you're reviewing may not be accurate. And so there's a huge wealth of knowledge that you can get from the data that we're getting on the reporting, just from kind of the hard, hard data.

Bill Douglas: I'm gonna you to put your mentor hat on since you're you know, let your experience show. What would you tell another asset manager just starting this journey?

Taylor Kolle: I think with asset management, one of the best things is the

Taylor Kolle: It's gonna be increasingly more important that you are able to navigate those challenges well and that you're skilled in a lot of different areas rather than just financial analysis or just operational initiatives. It's gonna be more important than ever to be well rounded, especially with y how AI has developed and how that's being utilized, how data is readily available and how we make decisions on that data. A lot of data can point to different issues, and so it may be a capital basis issue or it may be an operational challenge. And so being able to address and navigate both are gonna be crucial.

Drew Hall: All right, Taylor, everything we've done so far is industry focused, of course. So here at the end of our recordings and our shows, we always like to do what we call the extra floor, just in the spirit of commercial real estate. So the extra floor is just instead of it being industry-focused questions, it's just gonna be three quick questions just about you, so that our listeners and our viewers can just get to know the personal side. so here's the first of those three questions. What would you say is a good piece of career or life advice that you have received.

Taylor Kolle: I think probably the best advice that I've received early in my career is know what you don't know. and not only that, but you may not always be the smartest person in the room, but you can control being the hardest worker in the room. And so I think both are very crucial. if you don't know the information that you're getting from an AI platform or a an enterprise model. Then you're not gonna be able to make the right assessment and decision based on that information that it's spitting out. And so you need to be able to navigate those issues and analyze and understand what you don't know. but also where you don't know something, you need to be able to be the hardest worker to go figure that out and for the future problem that pops up.

Bill Douglas: Well, what's one habit or practice that consistently makes you more effective?

Taylor Kolle: I think work hard, play hard. I think having a life outside the office, private equity, finance, it's a very demanding role and job. And so having a life outside the office gives you a lot of flexibility. So, you know, working out, going to hang out with friends, the things that keep you well rounded and keep you healthy are also the things that will make you better at your job.

Drew Hall: All right, Taylor, the last one. Would you consider yourself to be an early bird or a night owl? And has that changed?

Taylor Kolle: Definitely a night owl, but it's had to change significantly. getting up before I go to the office to go work out, because I know that at seven or eight o'clock when I get home, I'm not gonna have the energy to go get a workout in. and so that, but also, you know, getting into the office early and working harder or maybe getting ahead. For the week rather than sitting behind and showing up at eight thirty. getting into the office early has been definitely a harder challenge to navigate, but it's definitely a requirement if you want to be ahead of your competition.

Drew Hall: Yeah.

Bill Douglas: Well, it sounds like early goes into the category of working harder that you can control what you just referenced. I like how you wove all of those together. So Taylor, how can our listeners contact you? The information will be on the show notes page too for all the listeners, but for the audio only folks.

Taylor Kolle: Yeah, absolutely. So you can reach out to Taylor at reef R E A F dot com. or you can connect with me on LinkedIn. I'm pretty active there and will respond to any messages. you can also reach out to our website. There's a contact us portion and get in touch with us there as well.

Bill Douglas: Awesome. Well, Taylor, thank you very much for the conversation, for the sharing, and thanks to all our listeners. We appreciate all of you. Be sure to, as Drew said, like, follow, subscribe, everything you can do to get the message out and share this with somebody. Send the episode to somebody and say, you should probably be on the show too. So to everybody out there, we'll see you on the next episode of Peak Property Performance.

Get Started

Three ways in.

Whether you're scouting, training camp, or game time, there's a way to start today.